Powered By Blogger

Monday, April 5, 2010

Why Children Hate To Read: For Starters

Sadly, today I spent lots of time at the doctor's office and in the hospital. Don't worry, everything is fine. Knowing me and my impatient self, I decided none of the magazines were worth my time so I thought maybe I could get a kick out of reading a children's book called "Not Norman".

I opened the first page of the book and began reading. By the second page, in my mind I was thinking "wow, this kid is a brat". To summarize the book, I will just say that a kid for his birthday received a goldfish from his parents as a gift and he was not happy because he wanted a "real" pet, I recall the book even describing that he wanted a pet that he could play with, sleep with, run around with, etc. The pictures also imply that the kid is hurting the goldfish's feelings. Yes, I know it is a goldfish and in reality, if a kid didn't want a goldfish, it wouldn't cry, but I started wondering if in the long run, it makes kids believe that it is ok to hurt someone's feelings by either mocking them, bullying them, or not wanting to be their friend.

As I continue reading this book, I try to figure out where it is going. Was it trying to tell children that it is ok not to appreciate presents? He wanted to return his goldfish and trade it for something "cooler", he even tries to sell it to his classmates. I then ask myself, why am I reading this? Not only was the message terrible, but the book itself was boring and the character was conveyed as rude. Just so that I could generate a valid opinion, I continued to read the book and of course there was the happy ending where the kid finally accepted the goldfish and wanted to keep it.

Then it occurred to me, books like these were the very reason I hated reading in elementary school. Boring books with characters like the one in this book made me hate reading (and don't get me started on the reading passages that are given to you for standardized testing. If you really want a child to do well on a test, give them passages that will be somewhat interesting).

So then I started thinking back to when I actually developed the desire to read. I did not like reading until about 10th grade when I discovered Stephen King, then after my interest developed, I moved to other authors. Yes, Stephen King may be considered a freak to most people but admit it, the guy can write a novel and keep you interested. Now I am not saying Stephen King is what elementary students should be reading but I am saying that books should be written in order to encourage students to develop the desire to read. Make it interesting and fun, and I think that should apply to not only elementary school but middle school and high school as well. Point is, if kids are reading books like "Not Norman" and are even half as bored as I was, you're teaching them right off the bat that reading is boring.

Now for my point- STOP GIVING CHILDREN A BORING SELECTION OF BOOKS! Reading is a good thing!
If you have an interest in writing or even think that I made a point in this blog, have you ever considered writing children's books? The thought crossed my mind and I am heavily considering it. If you are too, get busy!

2 comments:

  1. First of all, you would make a great children's author. Most authors these days are crap.

    Second of all let me talk from the perspective of someone who generally dislikes reading - make it useful! I know that you, Tina, sometimes do like to read just for the sake of reading. I don't. I read with purpose, and I always have done so. Call my breed rare, but I think many boys dislike reading from an early age for the same reason as me. Therefore I think books, yes even kid's books, need to have a reason to be read. I don't just mean a pie in the sky "moral" either. Kids don't wanna read that deep.

    Make an easily understood how-to book. Or a game book like "I Spy". Those are the only books I would read back in the day. Another good tactic I've read is to involve the reader by helping them craft their own story. "If this happens turn to page so-and-so". I loved those books too. Kind of reminds me of a video game when taken to the logical extreme...

    ReplyDelete
  2. unlike john i like reading for fun but no book really holds my attention (besides the pendragon series and encyclopedia brown) also i think you just got a crap book i mean Dr.Seuss's books are fun and so is the hungry caterpillar

    ps i still like a lot of children's books

    ReplyDelete